An interview at Bryant-Lake Bowl with four Twin Cities performing arts critics: Quinton Skinner (City Pages), Camille LeFevre, Dominic Papatola (Pioneer Press), and Graydon Royce (Star Tribune).
0:00.00: How did you become a critic? Dominic put his two loves together; Quinton stumbled in to it.
03:45.01: How do you fit in to the performing arts community? The critic lives in a “no man’s land” between the artists and the media.
06:30.14: Are you an arts advocate? Advocacy is different than boosterism.
10:22.19: Who are your readers? Quinton: “the coolest, most adventuress crowd;” Camille: “a certain amount of intelligence.”
14:52.25: Are you in a “conversation” with artists? Where the critics say that they want you to call them.
19:33.29: Do you approach each show differently? “Going native,” giving shows “the benefit of the doubt,” and copping to biases.
26:03.28: Does size matter? The smaller the review, the less the context will be in it, and the more insights are left out.
32:24.10: What is the future of arts criticism? Blogs, new business models, theater as a reflection of the local community, and “the tyranny of limitless opinion.”
36:52.08: What do you want from the performing arts? “All I want . . . is I want my life to be changed.”
Submitted by Puckeridge on February 23, 2009 - 8:00pm.
Someone as acute as Dominic Papatola = someone as
svelte as Oprah Winfrey
bentg gets it right: A person who sees a lot of theater does not necessarily become an expert on theater. Exhibit A: Dominic, who has never in his career made an original observation or displayed any real insight into anything.
Theater people of the Twin Cities - stop sucking up to these idiots! You know you don't respect them; their vehicles (the daily newspapers) are dying; and it doesn't matter what they say about your shows, since they have no influence any more.
Why not tell these stupid assholes what you really think of them? People of the theater, unite! You have nothing to lose but your chains!
I was a little crestfallen to hear someone as acute as Dominic Papatola basically say that seeing a bunch of theatre equals knowing a bunch about theatre. If this was truly how the world worked, my fat-ass cousin would’ve won the Daytona 500 by now.
The best writers or electronic communicators, whether of straight news or editorial content, are those who assume a high level of intelligence among their audience, and then direct their voices to that level within the contexts and constraints of the forum in which their work is expressed. That's much more rare than we hope it to be for any content in any forum, and readers, listeners, and viewers recognize and appreciate good communication when they encounter it.
There are 7 billion people on the planet and none of them are going to concern themselves with every communicator or utterance. My friend, Nick N., says we need to appreciate and encourage the effort of every artist, even if -- and especially if -- their work does not find a wide audience for 150 years. Same is true for every communicator.
Only in Minnesota (well, maybe North Dakota, too) would the video producers flash "Fight" on the screen before the last segment. That was no fight between Gray and Dom, but it was a good example of what is wrong with much of tv and video these days (and some of the arts?): the constant hype. "We" seem to be so uncertain of the value of what we are doing and its ability to engage people that we think it necessary to hype them to stay tuned for the next freaky attraction -- which ends up being not freaky at all.
Submitted by aberks on February 17, 2009 - 11:07am.
I agree with you that in part "what is wrong with much of tv and video" is the tendency to sensationalize lives that are and can be interesting in and of themselves.
I'd like to think, however, that anyone who has been enjoying our website, anyone who sat through a thoughtful and uniquely long web video in which the local critics got to demystify what they do in their own words, wouldn't see sensationalization in any of what we're doing here.
We enjoyed that little bit of disagreement between Dominic and Graydon; it's the kind of difference of opinion we (the performing arts community) never get to see up close, in general, and it was amusing in specific (to us, I guess) for the way that Dominic seemed to be egging Graydon on. However, it didn't fit in to the arc of the rest of the interview. We wanted to include it, just for fun, and -- living in MN as we do -- the irony of using the word fight was as apparent to us as it was, apparently, annoying to you. Our apologies for the misnomer.
Regardless, we're really quite excited that someone got to the end of the video! Thanks.
Comments
Someone as acute as Dominic
Someone as acute as Dominic Papatola = someone as
svelte as Oprah Winfrey
bentg gets it right: A person who sees a lot of theater does not necessarily become an expert on theater. Exhibit A: Dominic, who has never in his career made an original observation or displayed any real insight into anything.
Theater people of the Twin Cities - stop sucking up to these idiots! You know you don't respect them; their vehicles (the daily newspapers) are dying; and it doesn't matter what they say about your shows, since they have no influence any more.
Why not tell these stupid assholes what you really think of them? People of the theater, unite! You have nothing to lose but your chains!
Lamest. Fight. Ever.
I was a little crestfallen to hear someone as acute as Dominic Papatola basically say that seeing a bunch of theatre equals knowing a bunch about theatre. If this was truly how the world worked, my fat-ass cousin would’ve won the Daytona 500 by now.
Gary Peterson,
Gary Peterson, http://minnesotamist.blogspot.com
Interesting discussion.
The best writers or electronic communicators, whether of straight news or editorial content, are those who assume a high level of intelligence among their audience, and then direct their voices to that level within the contexts and constraints of the forum in which their work is expressed. That's much more rare than we hope it to be for any content in any forum, and readers, listeners, and viewers recognize and appreciate good communication when they encounter it.
There are 7 billion people on the planet and none of them are going to concern themselves with every communicator or utterance. My friend, Nick N., says we need to appreciate and encourage the effort of every artist, even if -- and especially if -- their work does not find a wide audience for 150 years. Same is true for every communicator.
Only in Minnesota (well, maybe North Dakota, too) would the video producers flash "Fight" on the screen before the last segment. That was no fight between Gray and Dom, but it was a good example of what is wrong with much of tv and video these days (and some of the arts?): the constant hype. "We" seem to be so uncertain of the value of what we are doing and its ability to engage people that we think it necessary to hype them to stay tuned for the next freaky attraction -- which ends up being not freaky at all.
Fight
I agree with you that in part "what is wrong with much of tv and video" is the tendency to sensationalize lives that are and can be interesting in and of themselves.
I'd like to think, however, that anyone who has been enjoying our website, anyone who sat through a thoughtful and uniquely long web video in which the local critics got to demystify what they do in their own words, wouldn't see sensationalization in any of what we're doing here.
We enjoyed that little bit of disagreement between Dominic and Graydon; it's the kind of difference of opinion we (the performing arts community) never get to see up close, in general, and it was amusing in specific (to us, I guess) for the way that Dominic seemed to be egging Graydon on. However, it didn't fit in to the arc of the rest of the interview. We wanted to include it, just for fun, and -- living in MN as we do -- the irony of using the word fight was as apparent to us as it was, apparently, annoying to you. Our apologies for the misnomer.
Regardless, we're really quite excited that someone got to the end of the video! Thanks.