The Root Beer Lady Returns to History Theatre

The Root Beer Lady returns to the History Theatre in St. Paul after it proved to be a hit with audiences in its initial 2023 run. That production which I also reviewed ended with a standing ovation, that continued for nearly a minute after it’s star and writer Kim Schultz left the stage. I’m not sure they needed to bring it back this soon but one thing’s for certain, Minnesotans love their Root Beer Lady and Kim Schultz once again brought her vividly to life for us on stage. Dorothy Molter, was a fascinating woman who made her own way in a mans world. She was a true trailblazer and the kind of person that becomes something of a folk hero around whom a mythology springs up. If you don’t know much or anything about Ms. Molter, do yourself a favor and don’t google her. Instead, get yourself some tickets and learn about her from Kim Schultz and her wonderful play. This was my second time and I think I may have enjoyed it even more this time. Schultz embodies Dorothy so completely that one comes away feeling you’ve just spent 90 minutes with the real Root Beer lady of the north.

Schultz heard about Molter during a stay in Tofte, MN. Fascinated by what she’d heard, she found a book written about her in the Tofte library. After reading that and doing some more research she began writing this one person show. I really don’t want to say much about her story as I knew little going in, and not knowing all the details was a wonderful gift. Molter moved permanently to Knife Lake in the Boundary Waters area of Northern MN after spending three summers working at the Isle of Pines Resort for her friend Bill. She never left, becoming the last resident of what became the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness. Her story is about the love she had for the area and her determination to live her life the way she wanted to, where she wanted to, in a time when that wasn’t really done. The story is full of humor and emotion, astonishing facts, and moments that will leave you in awe of what Molter was capable of. It’s an inspirational true life tale of real Minnesota original, and I found my eyes got a little watery by the end. She is an example of the ways in which people touch each others lives. When the going gets rough, the woman the Saturday Evening Post dubbed, the “Loneliest woman in America” always found that she had many, many, many friends.

It’s clear that Kim Schultz connected with Molter as her portrayal is so affectionate. She embraces the wonder of a young Molter experiencing the majesty of the wilderness, and gradually over the course of 80 minutes imperceptibly changes into the mature woman who spent 56 years living in the place she fell in love with. From a wonderstruck young woman to a full blown wilderness character, effortlessly and believably. While it’s definitely Schultz’s show, she gets some wonderful assistance with the production. Chelsea M. Warren’s set is a wonderful combination of Molter’s cabin and the outdoors with large tree trunks towering into the rafters and a canoe beached on the shoreline. Leslie Ritenour’s video design creates a background that changes the season, shows us the beautiful blue skies of a sunny day and the millions of stars in the night sky. Finally, Katharine Horowitz sound design creates an aurel soundscape that engulfs the audience. The constant sound of the lake, the animals sounds and the wind that accompanies a blizzard are just a few of the touches that stand out and help create the illusion of being up north with Dorothy.

The Root Beer Lady runs through February 23rd at the History Theatre for more information and to purchase tickets go to https://www.historytheatre.com/2024-2025/root-beer-lady